April 1st, 2023
Aaron Viner
Energy
projects boost land values
Rising land values have been one of the constants in the agriculture
industry, but adding energy projects is likely to provide additional
value.
Jim Rebhuhn, accredited farm manager with Hertz Farm Management in
Mt. Vernon, Iowa, said adding a wind turbine to any ground is a good
way to boost its value. The same is likely true of solar panels, but
there isn’t enough data to make a definite statement on that yet.
“The most data we have is on wind turbines, because they’ve been
around longer than some of these solar farms. But in just about
every case, when a farm sells and it has a turbine on it, we are
seeing a premium,” Rebhuhn said.
Part of the reason for that premium has to do with the contracts and
payments put in place when the energy projects were built. Those
agreements provide additional income for whoever owns the land,
which makes it more valuable.
“Whether you are a farmer or investor, you look at the property and
say ‘Hey, it generates X number of dollars over and above what corn
and soybeans would return,’” Rebhuhn said. “They are willing to pay
more because of that, and that’s what buyers are looking at in terms
of purchase decisions.”
Wendong Zhang, who leads Iowa State University’s land value survey
each year, said that in previous research they have found solar
installations don’t have as much impact on farm land values,
primarily because the covered area is unable to be farmed. He also
noted wind turbines may not have as big of an effect.
“A group of economists in Kansas looked at transaction data and
didn’t detect statistically higher prices or lower prices for
farmland with proximity to turbines,” he said.
One of the primary concerns with energy projects is with appearance.
Nearby homeowners and landowners don’t want the equipment to be in
their line of sight.
Despite that, land values are not decreasing for nearby homes, Zhang
said. The addition of solar panels may in fact bring added value to
the land overall.
“Think of, in northwest Iowa where there are animal feeding
operations, there are studies that show in general residential
homeowners don’t like the smells and there is evidence your housing
values could be affected by that,” he said.
Rebhuhn said while the value of the land may increase, there is
still a human element at play when determining just how much the
view of solar panels and wind turbines affects the current
homeowners. He said if the land is owned by a farmer or someone who
lives on the land, it is likely to be a tougher decision to add
these projects compared to an investor who isn’t likely to be around
the land often.
“When there’s a turbine right in your backyard, it certainly takes a
different approach versus on a farm when you don’t live in the
area,” Rebhuhn said. “Certainly you are trying to be a good
neighbor, but there’s less of an impact on you when you don’t see it
every day.”
Rebhuhn said solar tends to be less visually invasive overall, but
large scale projects tend to bring out complaints from neighbors who
are used to seeing rolling hills of corn and soybeans compared to
solar panels.
He said when planning where to put a project, wind turbines are
easier to place if the land allows. Average wind speeds tend to be
the biggest factor for wind turbine location. That is why many wind
projects were placed in northwest Iowa, southwest Minnesota or in
North Dakota and South Dakota.
But there are other things to consider as well.
“A lot comes based on how close you are to the grid, especially with
solar, and so we are seeing things crop up a bit in different
locations,” he said. “Those other areas are a bit more saturated so
they are moving to other areas that maybe might not produce quite as
much, but it’s closer to the grid.”
For solar, farmers could look at the feasibility of using corners of
fields that may be lower-quality land and leaving the best ground
for farming, he said.
Zhang said no matter what decision is made or what energy is
produced, landowners need to understand what they are getting into
when they enter these agreements.
“It’s best to have really good legal advice so that you really kind
of know or can identify the pitfalls,” he said. “There are a lot of
attorneys who specialize in the area of solar and wind, so that’s
one thing we’d recommend.”
Green Play Ammonia™, Yielder® NFuel Energy.
Spokane, Washington. 99212
www.exactrix.com
509 995 1879 cell, Pacific.
exactrix@exactrix.com
|